Best Personal Injury Lawyers in Jacksonville, Florida

Ranked by client review analysis. Based on 3,163 verified Google reviews across 20 firms. Data updated April 2026.

20
Firms Analyzed
13,496
Total Reviews
4.88
Avg Market Rating
62%
Avg Response Rate
6,600
Monthly Searches

Key Findings: Jacksonville Personal Injury Market (2026)

Based on our analysis of 3,163 client reviews across 20 personal injury law firms in Jacksonville, Florida, the average firm rating is 4.88 out of 5.0 with a median of reviews per firm. 15 of 20 firms maintain a rating of 4.9 or above.

The most valued quality among Jacksonville personal injury clients is recommendation, followed by communication and case results. Firms in this market respond to an average of 62% of client reviews , with Law Offices of Stephen A. Smith leading at 100%. Pajcic & Pajcic has the highest recommendation rate at 100%.

70% of Jacksonville personal injury attorneys and law firms are available 24/7 and 30% offer online appointments. The most-reviewed firm is Morgan & Morgan with 5,640 total Google reviews. The average Google Ads CPC for "personal injury lawyer Jacksonville" is $94.49, reflecting high case values and competitive demand in this market. Approximately 6,600 people search for a personal injury lawyer in Jacksonville each month.

Personal Injury Attorneys in Jacksonville: Market Overview

Jacksonville, Florida, with a population exceeding 900,000, represents a significant legal market for personal injury cases. The city’s extensive network of major highways, including I-95, I-10, and the I-295 beltway, contributes to a high volume of traffic-related accidents, while its diverse economy—spanning shipping, manufacturing, and construction—also results in workplace injuries and other liability claims. These factors drive steady demand for legal representation in personal injury matters, reflected by approximately 6,600 monthly online searches for “personal injury lawyer Jacksonville.”

Analysis of 20 personal injury law firms in Jacksonville, based on 13,496 client reviews, reveals a highly competitive market with an average firm rating of 4.88 out of 5. This indicates that local attorneys generally maintain strong client satisfaction. The average cost-per-click (CPC) for related online advertising is $94.49, suggesting a substantial investment in digital marketing to attract clients. Collectively, these metrics highlight both the quality of legal services available and the competitive environment among personal injury attorneys in the Jacksonville area.

All 20 Personal Injury Law Firms in Jacksonville Ranked

1

Pajcic & Pajcic

1 E Independent Dr #1900, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-358-8881

100% of reviewers explicitly recommend this firm — highest recommendation rate in Jacksonville.

4.9
709 reviews
Response Rate
94%
Recommend Rate
100%
Communication
40%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
689 five-star 16 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (100%)professionalism (48%)communication (40%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticewrongful death
2

Baggett Law Personal Injury Lawyers

9471 Baymeadows Rd #105, Jacksonville, FL 32256

+1904-447-2820

Perfect 5.0 rating with zero negative reviews in our 200-review sample.

5
433 reviews
Response Rate
97%
Recommend Rate
62%
Communication
17%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
430 five-star 3 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (61.5%)professionalism (34%)compassion (20.5%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcyclemedical malpracticewrongful deathproduct liability
3

Morgan & Morgan

501 Riverside Ave #1200, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-398-2722

Responds to 95% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.

4.6
5,640 reviews
Response Rate
95%
Recommend Rate
25%
Communication
17%
Consistency
Mixed
Rating Distribution
4611 five-star 371 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (24.5%)results (18.5%)professionalism (17.5%)
Case types handled:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurywrongful death
4

Fasig | Brooks Law Offices

301 W Bay St Ste 1471-72, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-299-1643

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (57% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

5
159 reviews
Response Rate
24%
Recommend Rate
57%
Communication
16%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
157 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (57%)professionalism (26.6%)communication (16.4%)
Case types handled:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
5

Baggett Law Personal Injury Lawyers Downtown Jacksonville

121 W Forsyth St #1000, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-875-8327

Responds to 97% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.

5
256 reviews
Response Rate
97%
Recommend Rate
44%
Communication
14%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
255 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (44.3%)professionalism (24.4%)communication (14.2%)
Case types handled:
car accidenttruck accidentmedical malpracticewrongful death
6

Henry Gare Personal Injury Attorney

1719 Emerson St, Jacksonville, FL 32207

+1904-387-6101

Perfect 5.0 rating with zero negative reviews in our 200-review sample.

5
359 reviews
Response Rate
84%
Recommend Rate
67%
Communication
13%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
358 five-star 0 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (66.5%)results (18.5%)professionalism (18%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcyclemedical malpractice
7

David Alan Wolf, Personal Injury Attorney

1702 Emerson St #2A, Jacksonville, FL 32207

+1904-500-9653

Perfect 5.0 rating with zero negative reviews in our 200-review sample.

5
514 reviews
Response Rate
42%
Recommend Rate
84%
Communication
15%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
512 five-star 0 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (84%)professionalism (42.5%)expertise (23%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcyclemedical malpracticedog bite
8

Pencheff and Fraley Injury and Accident Attorneys

1437 San Marco Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32207

+1904-770-4953

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (75% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.9
122 reviews
Response Rate
94%
Recommend Rate
75%
Communication
19%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
118 five-star 3 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (75%)professionalism (22.2%)results (19.4%)
Case types handled:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpractice
9

Gillette Law, P.A.

603 N Market St, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-600-4758

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (65.3% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.9
193 reviews
Response Rate
0%
Recommend Rate
65%
Communication
14%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
184 five-star 5 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (65.3%)professionalism (45.5%)communication (13.8%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmedical malpracticewrongful death
10

Farah & Farah | Jacksonville Personal Injury and Car Accident Lawyers

10 W Adams St, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-549-6434

Responds to 99% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.

5
3,080 reviews
Response Rate
99%
Recommend Rate
72%
Communication
44%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
2940 five-star 2 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (71.5%)professionalism (47%)communication (43.5%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurywrongful death
11

Wood, Atter & Wolf

12574 Flagler Center Blvd Suite 101, Jacksonville, FL 32258

+1904-355-8888

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (77.5% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.9
247 reviews
Response Rate
2%
Recommend Rate
78%
Communication
10%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
240 five-star 3 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (77.5%)professionalism (37.5%)expertise (18%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcyclemedical malpractice
12

Jacksonville Personal Injury Attorney

542 Edgewood Ave S, Jacksonville, FL 32205

+1904-800-7557

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (50% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.9
32 reviews
Response Rate
0%
Recommend Rate
50%
Communication
20%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
31 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (50%)communication (20%)professionalism (20%)
13

Hatfield & Hatfield, P.A.

210 E Forsyth St, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-446-9990

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (58.7% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.9
180 reviews
Response Rate
86%
Recommend Rate
59%
Communication
15%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
174 five-star 2 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (58.7%)professionalism (32.2%)results (18.2%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmedical malpractice
14

Harrell & Harrell P.A.

4735 Sunbeam Rd, Jacksonville, FL 32257

+1904-251-1111

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (81% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.6
604 reviews
Response Rate
90%
Recommend Rate
81%
Communication
31%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
525 five-star 46 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (81%)professionalism (41%)communication (30.5%)
Case types handled:
car accidenttruck accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
15

Terrell Hogan Law

233 E Bay St #804, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-632-2424

Responds to 98% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.

4.9
101 reviews
Response Rate
98%
Recommend Rate
66%
Communication
30%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
96 five-star 3 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (66%)expertise (35.1%)communication (29.8%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticewrongful death
16

Law Offices of Stephen A. Smith

101 E Union St #200, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-357-0090

Responds to 100% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.

4.9
207 reviews
Response Rate
100%
Recommend Rate
56%
Communication
14%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
201 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (55.6%)professionalism (40.1%)expertise (17.9%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmotorcyclemedical malpractice
17

Coker Law Jacksonville

136 E Bay St #5438, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-356-6071

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (64% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.7
96 reviews
Response Rate
12%
Recommend Rate
64%
Communication
27%
Consistency
High
Rating Distribution
88 five-star 6 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (64%)professionalism (37.1%)communication (27%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmedical malpracticewrongful death
18

Friedland Law, Car Accident and Personal Injury Attorneys - Jacksonville

6620 Southpoint Dr S Suite 115-E, Jacksonville, FL 32216

+1800-210-4878

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (63.5% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.8
265 reviews
Response Rate
66%
Recommend Rate
64%
Communication
16%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
249 five-star 7 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (63.5%)professionalism (22.5%)results (18%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmedical malpractice
19

Campione Law P.A.

501 W Bay St, Jacksonville, FL 32202

+1904-990-8400

Clients most frequently praise recommendation (71.7% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.

4.8
179 reviews
Response Rate
19%
Recommend Rate
72%
Communication
27%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
168 five-star 7 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (71.7%)professionalism (33.3%)communication (27%)
Case types handled:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpractice
20

Blakeley Car Accident & Personal Injury Lawyers Jacksonville

4600 Touchton Rd Suite 150, Jacksonville, FL 32246

+1904-821-7816

Perfect 5.0 rating with zero negative reviews in our 117-review sample.

5
120 reviews
Response Rate
33%
Recommend Rate
78%
Communication
13%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
120 five-star 0 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (77.8%)professionalism (24.8%)results (17.9%)
Case types handled:
car accidentmedical malpractice

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do personal injury lawyers charge in Florida?

Based on our data for Jacksonville, Florida. See individual firm profiles above for detailed metrics.

What not to say to a personal injury lawyer?

Based on our data for Jacksonville, Florida. See individual firm profiles above for detailed metrics.

What are the 4 proofs of negligence?

Based on our data for Jacksonville, Florida. See individual firm profiles above for detailed metrics.

How much of a $100K settlement will I get?

Based on our data for Jacksonville, Florida. See individual firm profiles above for detailed metrics.

Personal Injury Lawyers in Other Cities

Our Methodology

Law Leaderboard analyzes publicly available data to provide objective comparisons of lawyers, attorneys, and law firms. Our data sources include Google Business profiles, verified client reviews, and market intelligence. Every attorney and law firm profile on this page is derived from real client feedback — not paid placements or self-reported ratings.

Review analysis uses NLP keyword frequency extraction across 3,163 verified Google Reviews to identify patterns in client satisfaction, communication quality, and case outcomes. We compute metrics like owner response rate, recommendation percentage, and communication scores that traditional lawyer directories don't publish. Read our full methodology.

Last updated: April 2026. Data is refreshed monthly.