Who ranks highest in New York?
The Law Office of Richard M. Kenny currently leads this page based on the review signals captured in the local dataset.
Best Personal Injury Lawyers in New York, New York
This market tracks 6,239 public Google reviews, retrieves 6,237 review records, and analyzes 5,202 text reviews across 20 firms. Data updated April 2026.
20
Firms Analyzed
6,239
Google Reviews Tracked
4.89
Avg Market Rating
79%
Avg Response Rate
18,100
Monthly Searches
What This Page Answers
Use this page to compare personal injury firms in New York by local ranking, review behavior, and market context.
Which firms stand out on response and communication?
This page highlights firm-level response rates, recommendation rates, communication mentions, and review consistency so you can compare service quality instead of just star ratings.
How competitive is the New York market?
You can see total review volume, average market rating, monthly search demand, and the most commonly praised client experience signals in one place.
Standard Consumer Guidance
This page is designed for shortlist building. Use it to compare firms consistently before moving to direct outreach.
Use multiple signals, not one metric
Start with overall ranking, then compare response behavior, communication mentions, review volume, and rating distribution before calling any firm.
Review data is directional, not dispositive
This page helps with shortlist building. You should still verify fit, fee structure, case experience, and attorney availability before hiring.
Match the page to your use case
If you need city-level comparisons, stay here. If you need entity-level detail, click through to the full firm profile for deeper review analysis and sample reviews.
What Our Data Shows: Personal Injury Lawyers in New York, New York (2026)
New York City, with its dense population exceeding 8 million residents, represents one of the nation’s most active personal injury legal markets. The city's complex urban environment, characterized by heavy pedestrian traffic, extensive public transportation systems, and major highways such as the FDR Drive and the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway, contributes to a diverse range of accident types including motor vehicle collisions, slip and fall incidents, and construction-related injuries. Additionally, industries such as transportation, construction, and hospitality further influence the frequency and nature of personal injury claims in the area. This dynamic setting generates substantial demand for legal services, reflected in an average monthly search volume of 18,100 for “personal injury lawyer New York.”
Analysis of the local market shows 20 personal injury law firms actively serving the city, with a cumulative total of 6,239 client reviews reviewed to assess performance and reputation. These firms maintain a notably high average rating of 4.89 out of 5, suggesting strong client satisfaction and a competitive environment among attorneys. The average cost-per-click (CPC) for related online advertising is $64.32, indicating a significant investment in digital marketing to attract potential clients. Together, these data points highlight both the quality and intensity of competition within New York’s personal injury attorney landscape.
Across 5,202 text reviews analyzed in the current build from 20 personal injury law firms, the market shows an average rating of 4.89 out of 5.0. 14 of 20 firms maintain a rating of 4.9 or above. The most frequently praised quality among New York personal injury clients is professionalism — meaning clients consistently highlight how well attorneys communicate, keep them informed, and explain case progress.
Attorneys and law firms in this market respond to an average of 79% of client reviews , with Shulman & Hill - Manhattan Personal Injury Lawyer leading at 100%. The Law Offices of Eric Richman has the highest recommendation rate at 92%. 90% of firms are available 24/7 and 40% offer online appointments. The most-reviewed firm is Greenstein & Pittari, LLP with 732 total Google reviews.
Approximately 18,100 people search for a personal injury lawyer or attorney in New York each month. The average Google Ads CPC is $64.32, reflecting high case values and competitive demand.
Best For Common Shortlists
These callouts use the current review sample and the live ranking data already on this page. They are use-case shortcuts, not separate sponsored lists.
Highest Response Rate
Shulman & Hill - Manhattan Personal Injury Lawyer responds to 100% of tracked reviews, making it the strongest follow-up signal on this page.
Truck Accident Signal
Shulman & Hill - Brooklyn Personal Injury Lawyer is the highest-ranked firm on this page whose analyzed reviews mention truck accident matters.
Strongest Communication Mentions
Raphaelson & Levine Law Firm, P.C. has the strongest communication signal in the current sample, with communication referenced in 26% of analyzed reviews.
Most Reviews Tracked
Greenstein & Pittari, LLP has the largest public review footprint in this market with 732 total Google reviews tracked.
Firm Comparison Table
Use this table to compare the ranked personal injury firms in New York side by side before you drill into individual profiles.
20 Best Personal Injury Lawyers & Attorneys in New York, New York (2026 Rankings)
1
The Law Office of Richard M. Kenny
363 7th Ave 16th Floor, New York, NY 10001
+1844-955-4338
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (87% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
5 ★
353 reviews
Response Rate
69%
Recommend Rate
87%
Communication
13%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
348 five-star 2 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (87%)professionalism (43%)results (18.2%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurydog bite
2
Shulman & Hill - Manhattan Personal Injury Lawyer
1 State St 15th Floor, New York, NY 10004
+1917-905-2053
Responds to 100% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.
4.9 ★
437 reviews
Response Rate
100%
Recommend Rate
45%
Communication
15%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
423 five-star 2 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (44.5%)results (35.1%)professionalism (25%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
3
Hill & Moin LLP - Accident Attorneys
111 Broadway # 810, New York, NY 10006
+1212-668-6000
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (69.8% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.9 ★
170 reviews
Response Rate
94%
Recommend Rate
70%
Communication
17%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
166 five-star 3 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (69.8%)professionalism (42.6%)results (19.8%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurydog bite
4
NYC Injury Attorneys P.C.
140 Broadway 46th Floor, PMB 300, New York, NY 10005
+1646-452-3663
Rated 4.9/5 based on 63 client reviews.
4.9 ★
63 reviews
Response Rate
92%
Recommend Rate
30%
Communication
8%
Consistency
High
Rating Distribution
57 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (30%)results (18.3%)speed (15%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
motorcycleslip and fall
5
Shulman & Hill - Brooklyn Personal Injury Lawyer
26 Court St #2216, Brooklyn, NY 11242
+1917-793-0637
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (59.9% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.9 ★
608 reviews
Response Rate
87%
Recommend Rate
60%
Communication
10%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
578 five-star 2 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (59.9%)professionalism (28.8%)results (25.9%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidenttruck accidentmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
6
Rosenbaum Personal Injury Lawyers
100 Wall St 15th Floor, New York, NY 10005
+1212-514-5007
Responds to 98% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.
4.8 ★
226 reviews
Response Rate
98%
Recommend Rate
65%
Communication
22%
Consistency
High
Rating Distribution
210 five-star 10 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (64.6%)professionalism (36.5%)communication (22.2%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
7
New York City Personal Injury Attorney at Law, Brandon J. Broderick
40 W 37th St #400b, New York, NY 10018
+1866-589-2013
Responds to 98% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.
5 ★
170 reviews
Response Rate
98%
Recommend Rate
12%
Communication
5%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
167 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
professionalism (22.9%)recommendation (11.5%)compassion (8.3%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accident
8
Law Offices of Jay S. Knispel Personal Injury Lawyers - New York City
450 7th Ave Suite 1605, New York, NY 10123
+1516-715-5944
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (84.1% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
5 ★
90 reviews
Response Rate
5%
Recommend Rate
84%
Communication
16%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
89 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (84.1%)professionalism (25.4%)results (19%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentslip and fall
9
Greenstein & Pittari, LLP
1825 Park Ave, New York, NY 10035
+1212-685-8500
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (77.8% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.9 ★
732 reviews
Response Rate
88%
Recommend Rate
78%
Communication
24%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
689 five-star 18 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (77.8%)professionalism (37.2%)communication (24.2%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
10
Cellino Law Injury Attorneys
420 Lexington Ave #2001, New York, NY 10170
+1718-550-1692
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (68.3% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.8 ★
146 reviews
Response Rate
89%
Recommend Rate
68%
Communication
18%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
137 five-star 6 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (68.3%)professionalism (33.3%)results (23%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpractice
11
Hach & Rose, LLP
112 Madison Ave 10th floor, New York, NY 10016
+1646-663-3012
Responds to 95% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.
4.8 ★
264 reviews
Response Rate
95%
Recommend Rate
82%
Communication
25%
Consistency
High
Rating Distribution
246 five-star 9 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (82.1%)professionalism (37.5%)results (27.7%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurywrongful death
12
The Perecman Firm, P.L.L.C.
250 W 57th St #401, New York, NY 10107
+1646-536-2089
Responds to 95% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.
4.9 ★
719 reviews
Response Rate
95%
Recommend Rate
55%
Communication
11%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
694 five-star 14 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (54.5%)professionalism (26.6%)results (18.7%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
13
De Caro & Kaplen, LLP
228 E 45th St Suite 1100, New York, NY 10017
+1212-732-2262
Rated 4.9/5 based on 183 client reviews.
4.9 ★
183 reviews
Response Rate
92%
Recommend Rate
28%
Communication
2%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
175 five-star 3 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (27.7%)expertise (14.2%)professionalism (12.8%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentmedical malpracticewrongful death
14
Meirowitz & Wasserberg, LLP
1040 6th Ave 10th Fl, New York, NY 10018
+1646-860-0895
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (60.4% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.9 ★
193 reviews
Response Rate
68%
Recommend Rate
60%
Communication
19%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
186 five-star 5 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (60.4%)professionalism (30.8%)compassion (20.3%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidenttruck accidentmotorcycleslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurywrongful deathdog bite
15
The Law Offices of Eric Richman
641 Lexington Ave 14th Floor, New York, NY 10022
+1212-688-3965
92% of reviewers explicitly recommend this firm — highest recommendation rate in New York.
5 ★
184 reviews
Response Rate
85%
Recommend Rate
92%
Communication
23%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
183 five-star 1 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (92.2%)professionalism (40.8%)expertise (24%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injury
16
Raphaelson & Levine Law Firm, P.C.
14 Pennsylvania Plaza Suite 1718, New York, NY 10122
+1646-960-3476
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (73.8% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.8 ★
698 reviews
Response Rate
81%
Recommend Rate
74%
Communication
26%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
662 five-star 22 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (73.8%)professionalism (36.7%)results (30.4%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidentslip and fallmedical malpracticeworkplace injurydog bite
17
Hansen & Rosasco, LLP
250 Broadway Suite 600, New York, NY 10007
+1212-210-1762
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (56.3% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.9 ★
402 reviews
Response Rate
66%
Recommend Rate
56%
Communication
23%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
394 five-star 5 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (56.3%)professionalism (46.1%)communication (23.2%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
medical malpracticeworkplace injurywrongful death
18
Block O'Toole & Murphy
1 Pennsylvania Plaza Suite 4850, New York, NY 10119
+1212-736-5300
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (87.2% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.8 ★
182 reviews
Response Rate
1%
Recommend Rate
87%
Communication
22%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
173 five-star 6 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (87.2%)professionalism (45.7%)results (29.9%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accidenttruck accidentmotorcyclemedical malpracticeworkplace injury
19
The Ward Law Group, PLLC
535 5th Ave Suite 910, New York, NY 10017
+1646-956-2797
Responds to 97% of client reviews, demonstrating exceptional client engagement.
4.9 ★
327 reviews
Response Rate
97%
Recommend Rate
26%
Communication
2%
Consistency
Very High
Rating Distribution
315 five-star 7 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (26.3%)professionalism (21.1%)speed (7%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accident
20
Friedland Law
50 Broad St # 1502, New York, NY 10004
+1800-210-4878
Clients most frequently praise recommendation (50% of reviews) — significantly above the market average.
4.8 ★
92 reviews
Response Rate
77%
Recommend Rate
50%
Communication
10%
Consistency
High
Rating Distribution
87 five-star 5 one-star
Clients praise:
recommendation (50%)professionalism (24.3%)speed (12.9%)
Case types mentioned in reviews:
car accident
Frequently Asked Questions
These answers cover common hiring, fee, and case-value questions. Use this page for local firm comparison and the New York state page for state-law orientation.
What is the average personal injury settlement in New York?
There is no reliable citywide average settlement figure in this review dataset, and averages are often misleading. Case value usually depends on liability, treatment, lost income, permanency, policy limits, and how well damages are documented. Ask shortlisted firms how they would value a case with facts similar to yours.
Who is the best personal injury lawyer in New York?
This question depends heavily on case facts and state law. Use this city page to compare firms on response behavior, communication mentions, and review consistency, then use the state page for legal context and ask a shortlisted firm for guidance on your exact facts.
What are the 4 proofs of negligence?
This question depends heavily on case facts and state law. Use this city page to compare firms on response behavior, communication mentions, and review consistency, then use the state page for legal context and ask a shortlisted firm for guidance on your exact facts.
How much will I get from a $25,000 settlement?
This question depends heavily on case facts and state law. Use this city page to compare firms on response behavior, communication mentions, and review consistency, then use the state page for legal context and ask a shortlisted firm for guidance on your exact facts.
Personal Injury Lawyers in Other Cities
Atlanta, Georgia
20 firms | 4.9 avg
Austin, Texas
20 firms | 4.92 avg
Baltimore, Maryland
20 firms | 4.86 avg
Charlotte, North Carolina
20 firms | 4.92 avg
Chicago, Illinois
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Dallas, Texas
20 firms | 4.9 avg
Denver, Colorado
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Houston, Texas
20 firms | 4.85 avg
Jacksonville, Florida
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Las Vegas, Nevada
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Los Angeles, California
20 firms | 4.9 avg
Miami, Florida
20 firms | 4.9 avg
Minneapolis, Minnesota
20 firms | 4.85 avg
Nashville, Tennessee
20 firms | 4.86 avg
Orlando, Florida
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
20 firms | 4.87 avg
Phoenix, Arizona
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Portland, Oregon
20 firms | 4.87 avg
Sacramento, California
20 firms | 4.82 avg
San Antonio, Texas
20 firms | 4.89 avg
San Diego, California
20 firms | 4.91 avg
San Francisco, California
20 firms | 4.85 avg
Seattle, Washington
20 firms | 4.87 avg
Tampa, Florida
20 firms | 4.88 avg
Our Methodology
Law Leaderboard analyzes publicly available data to provide objective comparisons of lawyers, attorneys, and law firms. Our data sources include Google Business profiles, verified client reviews, and market intelligence. Every attorney and law firm profile on this page is derived from real client feedback — not paid placements or self-reported ratings.
Review analysis uses NLP keyword frequency extraction across 5,202 retrieved text reviews to identify patterns in client satisfaction, communication quality, and case outcomes. We compute metrics like owner response rate, recommendation percentage, and communication scores that traditional lawyer directories don't publish. Read our full methodology.
Last updated: April 2026. Data is refreshed monthly.
Sources, Freshness & Limitations
Sources
- • Google Business profile data for each listed firm, including ratings, review counts, business attributes, and local profile details.
- • 6,237 retrieved review records and 5,202 text reviews analyzed across 20 ranked firms in New York, New York.
- • Market-level search demand and CPC data for personal injury queries in New York.
Freshness
- • Current build date: April 2026.
- • 6,239 total Google reviews are tracked across this market, with 6,237 reviews retrieved and 5,202 text reviews analyzed in the current build.
- • The city page is a static ranking snapshot generated from the latest exported dataset in this build.
- • Methodology version: 2026.04.07. Exported at: 2026-04-06 22:46:09 UTC.
- • Latest source timestamps in scope — profiles: 2026-04-02 11:51:29, reviews: 2026-04-06 17:03:15, analysis: 2026-04-06 17:04:24.
Limitations
- • Tracked public review counts, retrieved review records, and text reviews analyzed are different counts and should not be treated as interchangeable.
- • Case-type signals indicate that a topic appears in analyzed reviews; they do not prove board certification or practice exclusivity.
- • Review-derived metrics help with shortlist building, but they do not replace direct lawyer interviews, fee review, or credential checks.