Gage Mathers Law Group Reviews, Ratings & Analysis

2525 E Arizona Biltmore Cir, Phoenix, AZ 85016

4.7
92 Google reviews
Verified Profile

Gage Mathers Law Group is a personal injury attorney in Phoenix, Arizona with a 4.7-star rating across 92 tracked Google reviews. The current build retrieved 92 reviews for this profile and analyzed 90 text reviews. The firm replies to 57% of public reviews, 80% of analyzed reviewers explicitly recommend it, and communication is mentioned in 23% of analyzed reviews. Its review pattern is fairly consistent based on a consistency index of 84.4.

The most common review themes are explicit recommendation (80%), professionalism (34%), and case results (26%). Reviews in the sample mention matters involving car accident, truck accident, motorcycle, and medical malpractice. Use these signals as due-diligence inputs rather than proof of specialty or likely outcome.

Firm Snapshot Table

Use this table to see the difference between the firm's public review footprint, the reviews retrieved into the current build, and the text reviews that feed the NLP metrics on this page.

MetricValueWhat it means
Tracked Google reviews92Public review count currently visible on the profile.
Reviews retrieved92Review records stored in the current build.
Text reviews analyzed90Review texts used for NLP-derived praise, complaint, and communication metrics.
Owner response rate57%Share of retrieved reviews with an owner reply.
Explicit recommendation rate80%Share of analyzed reviewers who explicitly recommend the firm.
Communication mentions23%Share of analyzed reviews that mention communication.
Consistency index84.4Higher scores indicate a more consistently positive rating pattern.

Case Types Mentioned in Reviews

car accidenttruck accidentmotorcyclemedical malpracticeproduct liability

Quick Stats

Reviews/Month
1
Avg Review Length
414 chars
Local Guide %
19%

Practice Areas

Civil law attorneyGeneral practice attorneyLaw firmAttorneyLegal servicesMedical lawyer

What Our Data Shows

The sections below break this firm into measurable signals: responsiveness, communication mentions, review consistency, praised attributes, complaint themes, and recent review examples. Read them together, not as isolated stats.

Performance Metrics

Based on analysis of 90 text reviews in the current build.

Owner Response Rate
57%
replies to reviews
Explicit Recommendation Rate
80%
of analyzed reviewers
Communication Mentions
23%
of analyzed reviews
Professionalism Mentions
34%
of analyzed reviews
Results Mentions
26%
of analyzed reviews
Compassion Mentions
11%
of analyzed reviews
Average response time: 110.9 days

Rating Distribution

5 star
84 (91%)
4 star
1 (1.1%)
3 star
0 (0%)
2 star
1 (1.1%)
1 star
6 (6.5%)
92% positive reviews 8% negative reviews Consistency index: 84.4

What Clients Praise

explicit recommendation 80% of reviews
professionalism 34.4% of reviews
case results 25.6% of reviews
communication 23.3% of reviews
dedication 15.6% of reviews

Common Concerns (from negative reviews)

unprofessional (28.6%)
poor communication (14.3%)

Recent Reviews

Fancy Nancy

Thank you so much to Gage Mathers! They always had my best interest at heart. They always took the time to make sure I understood everything and they fought for me! A special thank you to Matt Story for being by my side the whole time!

3 weeks ago
Sanja Habibic

This is a great team to hire! They truly care about you as a customer. Monique is the best paralegal, she returns calls fast and she truly makes every effort to answer all of your questions. I couldn’t be happier with all of them. They keep you posted throughout the whole process and you don’t feel ...

a month ago
Margaret Johnson

I had a wonderful experience and I am so thankful for the help of Matt Story on my personal injury case! I would highly recommend this firm.

a month ago
Lou Burgess

I cannot begin to express the depth of my gratitude and appreciation for the empathy, professionalism, and efficiency with which Matt Story and the Gage Mathers staff have handled my case - a case that dozens of other firms declined to take on. Rarely (if ever) have I been inclined to make such a re...

2 months ago
Nicole Carson

Joe, I just wanted to take a moment to thank you for all that you did for me. Your time and commitment meant a lot to me. I also want to thank Molly for all her time, and for getting back to me whenever I had a questions. When we first started this process, I was really sad and nervous about suing ...

2 months ago

Other Personal Injury in Phoenix

Sources, Freshness & Limitations

Sources

  • Google Business profile data for the firm, including address, phone, website, business attributes, and aggregate public rating.
  • 92 retrieved reviews and 90 text reviews used to calculate praise, complaint, communication, and response metrics for this profile.
  • Recent review excerpts and business details rendered from the same exported firm dataset used by the city rankings.

Freshness

  • Profile last scraped: 2026-04-02 12:08:16.
  • Profile last exported into the current build: 2026-04-02 12:08:16.
  • 92 total Google reviews tracked; 92 reviews retrieved; 90 text reviews analyzed.
  • Methodology version: 2026.04.07. Exported at: 2026-04-06 22:46:09 UTC.
  • Latest source timestamps in scope — profiles: 2026-04-02 12:08:16, reviews: 2026-04-02 12:12:45, analysis: 2026-04-06 17:04:24.

Limitations

  • Public review volume, retrieved review records, and text reviews analyzed are different counts and should not be treated as interchangeable.
  • Review-derived case-type and praise signals show what appears in the sample; they do not independently verify board certification or case outcomes.
  • This page helps you evaluate a firm’s public client-feedback footprint, but hiring decisions still require direct due diligence.
← View all Phoenix personal injury lawyers ranked by client reviews